Rolling and Torque
A ring, a disc, a hollow ball and a solid ball race down a ramp. Who wins, and why? Change the angle and size, then look inside the energy to find out.
Class 11 Rotational Motion71% moving · 29% spinning · I = ⅖ m r²
Try this
0 of 5 doneRun a race. Who wins: the ring, the balls or the disc?Hint: press Race!
Make a race so gentle that the ring takes more than 3 seconds.Hint: lower the ramp angle
Prove size doesn't matter: race twice with different sizes.Hint: change the size slider between two races
Find something that beats the solid ball.Hint: what if it didn't have to spin at all?
Find out how much of the ring's energy goes into spinning.Hint: pick the ring in the energy view
What's happening
Rolling means moving and spinning
A rolling object does two things at once: it moves down the slope and it spins. Gravity's energy has to be shared between the two. Whatever goes into spinning can't go into speed, so objects that are 'hard to spin' roll down more slowly.
Moment of inertia: how hard it is to spin
Moment of inertia, I, depends on how far the mass sits from the centre. A ring keeps all its mass at the rim, so it's hardest to spin. A solid ball keeps most of it near the middle, so it's easiest. That's why the solid ball always wins, whatever its mass or size.
Torque gets it spinning
Friction at the point of contact pushes up the slope, a little off-centre, and that makes a turning effect called torque. Torque spins the object up just as force speeds it up. Without friction (the ice block) nothing spins, and all the energy goes into speed.
Who figured this out?
Galileo Galilei
About 1604, ItalyRolled balls down long, gentle ramps and timed them, discovering that distance grows with the square of the time: the first careful study of acceleration.
Christiaan Huygens
1673, NetherlandsWhile studying swinging bodies he worked with the quantity Σ m r², the idea we now call moment of inertia.
Leonhard Euler
1765, SwitzerlandGave moment of inertia its name and wrote the equations for how solid objects spin and tumble.
Learn more
- Moment of inertia · Wikipedia
- Rolling · Wikipedia
- Torque · Wikipedia
Check yourself
1. A ring and a solid ball roll down the same ramp. Which reaches the bottom first?
2. You make the solid ball twice as heavy. Its time down the ramp…
3. What fraction of a rolling ring's kinetic energy is spinning energy?
4. What makes a ball start spinning as it rolls down a ramp?
Common questions
What is moment of inertia?
Moment of inertia (I) measures how hard it is to change an object's rotation, just as mass measures how hard it is to change its motion. It depends on the mass and how far it is from the axis: I = Σ m r². Mass far from the axis, as in a ring, gives a large moment of inertia.
Which reaches the bottom of an incline first: a ring, a disc or a sphere?
A solid sphere wins, then a solid disc (or cylinder), then a hollow sphere, and a ring comes last. The order depends only on the shape, through I/(mr²), not on the mass or radius.
What is rolling without slipping?
Rolling without slipping means the object rolls without skidding: the point touching the ground is momentarily at rest, and the speed of the centre is v = ωr, where ω is the angular speed. Static friction makes it spin but does no work, so no energy is lost.
What is the formula for torque?
Torque τ = r F sin θ, where r is the distance from the axis to where the force acts, F is the force and θ the angle between them. Torque causes angular acceleration: τ = I α, the rotational version of F = m a.
What is the acceleration of a body rolling down an inclined plane?
For rolling without slipping, a = g sin θ / (1 + I/(m r²)). For a solid sphere that is (5/7) g sin θ, for a disc (2/3) g sin θ and for a ring (1/2) g sin θ. An object sliding without friction has a = g sin θ.
What is the kinetic energy of a rolling body?
A rolling body has both translational and rotational kinetic energy: KE = ½ m v² + ½ I ω². For a ring the two parts are equal; for a solid sphere the spinning part is 2/7 of the total.
Rolling without slipping and no air resistance. Real balls lose a little energy to rolling resistance.
Play next
All simulationsProjectile Motion
Launch at any angle and speed, then find the angle that throws the farthest.
Forces and Friction
Push, pull and change the surface to see which forces win and why things stop.
Levers and Pulleys
Slide the fulcrum and add pulleys to lift a heavy load with less effort.